Sunset Key Cottages

Overview
Sunset Key Cottages sits on a 27-acre private island reached only by a 24/7 ferry from the Margaritaville marina, a seven-minute boat ride from Old Town Key West. With 40 one- to four-bedroom cottages, it offers one of the most secluded settings off Key West.
Good for
- Couples seeking a private island escape
- Families needing multi-bedroom space with full kitchens
- Water sports and beach lovers
Think twice if
- Guests who prefer walking to town over taking a ferry
- Travelers who want a conventional hotel layout rather than cottage-style accommodations
Who we wrote for
Sunset Key Cottages suits couples, honeymooners, and families who want a private island experience with beach access, water activities, and self-contained cottage living a short ferry ride from Key West.
Rooms and rates
One-Bedroom Cottage
Brightly painted cottage with a full kitchen, wraparound balcony or veranda, and luxe bathroom; garden or sea views depending on position.
Ideal for couples seeking a private island retreat with home-like comforts.Check rates →Two-Bedroom Cottage
Spacious two-bedroom cottage with full kitchen, private veranda, and options for oceanfront views; some units include a private pool.
Great for small families or two couples wanting extra space and beach proximity.Check rates →Three-Bedroom Cottage
Generous three-bedroom layout with full kitchen, wraparound balcony, and direct access to the exclusive beach; oceanfront views available.
Well suited to families or groups who want room to spread out steps from the sand.Check rates →Four-Bedroom Cottage
The largest unit on the island, with four bedrooms, a fully equipped kitchen, private veranda, and potential for a private pool.
Perfect for larger families or groups wanting the ultimate private-island experience.Check rates →Amenities
- Private white-sand beach
- Lagoon-style zero-entry swimming pool
- Flipper's Pool Bar
- Waterfront restaurant (Latitudes)
- Full-service spa
- Fitness center
- Tennis courts (lessons available)
- Library
- Games room
- Water sports (kayaking, jet skiing, snorkeling, diving, fishing, parasailing)
- Guided tours and sunset trips
- Fishing off the pier
- Daily breakfast basket delivered to cottage porch
- Poolside popsicles
- Daily spirits tastings
- 24/7 private ferry to mainland
- Concierge
Location
Key West FL. The island is reached by a private 24/7 ferry running between the Sunset Key dock and the Margaritaville marina in Key West — a seven-minute boat ride from Old Town.
Other stays nearby
In our guides
11 Best Hotels In Marmaris TurkeyDecember 7, 2025
11 Best Hotels in Old Town Key West FloridaAugust 21, 2024
11 Best Hotels Near Duval Street Key WestAugust 1, 2024
11 Best Luxury Hotels in Key West, FloridaJuly 7, 2024
11 Best Bed and Breakfast in Key WestMarch 15, 2024
11 Best Beachfront Hotels in Key WestAugust 1, 2022Questions people ask
How do you get to Sunset Key Cottages?
The only way to reach the property is by boat or ferry. A private ferry runs 24/7 between the island's dock and the Margaritaville marina, with the crossing taking about seven minutes.
What do the cottages include?
Cottages range from one to four bedrooms and come with full kitchens, wraparound balconies, and luxe bathrooms. Some cottages also have private pools.
What activities are available on the island?
The property offers a lagoon-style zero-entry swimming pool, a private white-sand beach, spa treatments, tennis courts, a fitness center, a library, a games room, and a full water sports program including kayaking, jet skiing, diving, fishing, snorkeling, and sunset trips arranged by the concierge.
Is breakfast included?
A breakfast basket with fruit and freshly baked pastries is delivered to your cottage porch every morning as part of the stay.


