11 Best Boutique Hotels in Key West

Key West is a bright and beautiful island city in the southernmost part of the United States. Travelers flock to Key West for water adventures, historical sites, lively nightlife, and beautiful architecture. The minute you touch down in Key West, your life will be more colorful than ever. For those searching for the best boutique hotel in Key West, you’ll be blown away by all the options. Key West is full of excellent and unique hotels with something special. Every hotel you visit has a different vibe. This article will talk about the most amazing hotels in Key West for a memorable holiday.

The Gardens Hotel

11

When you want to stay at a boutique hotel that feels so cozy and homey, you should check out The Gardens Hotel. This is the best boutique hotel in Key West for leisure travelers who love a laid-back atmosphere. The hotel also offers a personalized service to make you feel right at home.

This hotel was previously known as the Gardens Mansion, and it was built in the 1800s. Then Peggy Mills bought the building in 1930 and turned it into the Gardens Hotel Key West that it is today. The concept is about a beautiful botanical garden. This is where you sleep and are surrounded by beautiful flowers and plants.

When you stay here, make sure to pick the Master Suite. This room features an extravagant style with a king bedroom, living room, and private verandah. Besides, you have a private balcony or patio garden views. Moreover, each room also comes with a cable TV and refrigerator.

Andrews Inn & Garden Cottages

10

At Andrews Inn & Garden Cottages, your journey begins. This beautiful boutique hotel sits in a place where time slows down in tune with the island’s relaxed atmosphere. However, you still have easy access to the city’s most iconic areas like Duval Street and Hemingway House on foot.

The inspiring pool is nestled among a beautiful garden. This is the best spot to relax after a long day of exploration. Andrews Inn & Garden Cottages is not a massive hotel. This is why it’s a great place to connect with new people and have meaningful conversations with fellow travelers. 

Andrews Inn features elegant guest rooms with air conditioning, a high-speed Wi-Fi connection, and a smart TV. Besides, you’ll also find a coffee machine for your daily dose of coffee. Each room has a traditional Key West design, and you’ll see beautiful artwork by local artists. You’ll find yourself ultimately at ease staying at this hotel.

Silver Palms Inn

9

Silver Palms Inn is a modern boutique hotel in the heart of Old Town Key West. Escape the rut and enjoy the beauty and tranquility of Key West. This is where you get to witness turquoise blue water and gorgeous sunsets. Its island charm and outstanding hospitality make Silver Palms Inn the best boutique hotel in Key West for first-timers.

Silver Palms Inn is the perfect spot where you can relax and immerse yourself in new adventures. Whether you’re here for a solo weekend getaway or celebrating family vacation time, this hotel is truly a heaven for the soul. Need more options? Check out our list of the best family hotels in Key West.

After a busy day, get back to your room and unwind. The contemporary rooms and suites at Silver Palms Inn come with charming island décor and vibrant colors. Besides, this hotel offers an eco-friendly concept with more sustainable practices. This is an excellent place for environment-conscious travelers.

The Gates Hotel Key West

8

The Gates Hotel Key West is the best boutique hotel in Key West for a romantic getaway. This is a sun-soaked paradise where you can carve out beautiful memories with your partner. Discover the history and explore all the beautiful things Key West offers. The local touches immerse you in the breeze of Key West’s white-sand beaches.

Located on North Roosevelt Boulevard, The Gates Hotel is your base to explore Key West’s main attractions and iconic landmarks. This hotel has a unique laid-back atmosphere with modern design and retro Floridian flair.

The moment you enter the room, you’ll be greeted with a welcome cocktail. All the elegant guest rooms and suites come with a television, fridge, and an en suite bathroom with premium toiletries. Extras include coffee-making facilities and an inspiring pool view. You’re going to enjoy every second you spend here.

Old Town Manor

7

Relax in a charming hotel in the center of it all. Old Town Manor places you in a laid-back atmosphere in the heart of Old Town Key West. This beautiful and homey hotel was built in 1886. It has been part of Key West’s history for more than a century. The tropical gardens are a true reflection of Key West.

Feel at home at Old Town Manor as it offers an organic continental breakfast every morning. Besides, you can also bring your furry friend with you here. Old Town Manor sits only half a block from Duval Street and Mallory Square. This place comes with state-of-the-art amenities designed to enhance your stay.

After a day of exploring, get back to your superior queen room with a spacious deck overlooking the beautiful tropical gardens. All rooms come with free Wi-Fi and a television. But who needs a tv when you have a private balcony and a minibar? In the morning, enjoy a hearty breakfast, including pastries and organic fruits.

Truman Hotel

6

Enjoy an open and spacious design in a convenient location. Truman Hotel is the best hotel in Key West for business travelers and art enthusiasts. This award-winning hotel features a fantastic color palette, unique art, and elegant finish.

Staying at Truman Hotel means you’re in the middle of the fun. Here, you’re close to all the popular attractions in Key West. You can walk to Hemingway’s House, Sloppy Joe’s Bar, and famous museums from the hotel’s front door. Besides, you can also walk to the beach to watch the stunning sunset. Also, in your free time, you get to enjoy the courtyard and pool area.

Truman Hotel has a variety of rooms and suites. But all rooms come with work desks and leather chairs. Besides, you have plush bedding for a good night’s sleep. In the morning, head to the balcony that overlooks Truman Ave.

Havana Cabana at Key West

5

Immerse yourself in the good vibes of Key West at Havana Cabana at Key West. It’s a beautiful spot for your memorable vacation. You have everything to enjoy a good time. From mojitos to great music to art, you’ll find it all here.

Modern elegance and authentic Key West style can coexist here at Havana Cabana at Key West. This hotel features beautiful spacious rooms that are bright, airy, and cozy. With charming tropical design and top-notch amenities, surely you’ll enjoy your stay. Besides, you’re only steps from the beach to bask in the sun and enjoy the ocean breeze.

All rooms at Havana Cabana at Key West come with a large-screen TV with high-definition channels. Besides, you’ll find a fridge and a coffee machine for your daily dose of coffee. Additionally, the en suite comes with premium toiletries. An on-site hot tub is available if you want to use it in your free time.

Parrot Key Hotel & Villas

4

Welcome to Parrot Key Hotel & Villas, where your dream holiday becomes a reality. It’s a beautiful place that’s a gateway to all the best Key West offers. Besides, this is also the perfect place to enjoy a staycation. With inspiring pools, hammocks, and fun activities, you’ll never want to leave. All these – and more – make this the best hotel in Key West for modern travelers like you.

Explore and immerse yourself in island life at Parrot Key Hotel & Villas. This is your tropical adventure, and you get to do whatever you want. Enjoy beautiful nature right outside your room, or go downtown to discover something incredible.

Wander around the city and then return to your elegant and spacious room to rest and unwind. All the guest rooms and suites come with a 55-inch television and a small fridge. But the best thing is you can relax on your private terrace and enjoy the stunning tropical landscape.

Santa Maria Suites Resort

3

Santa Maria Suites Resort is an inspiring place to gather great ideas and reconnect with your authentic self. This is where you can truly embody the spirit of Key West and live slowly like everything is easy. Relax in the luxury lounge by courtyard pools. Or taste the most delicious artisan cuisine at the on-site restaurant. On a bright sunny day, walk down to the beach and enjoy the ocean breeze.

Santa Maria Suites Resort sits in the charming Old Town. Staying here means you’re only steps from epic restaurants, famous landmarks, and lively bars. This place offers a tranquil oasis where you can relax and unwind while enjoying the warmth of the sun. Let the attentive staff pamper you with outstanding service and hospitality.

Enjoy your spacious suites that feature a king-size bed, a designer kitchen, and a living room. Besides, you also have three large screens for maximum entertainment. And the best thing is, you have impressive views of the courtyard from your private patio. Enjoy a peaceful vibe at Santa Maria Suites Resort.

Hyatt Centric Key West Resort & Spa

2

Hyatt Centric Key West Resort & Spa is among the top 15 of Condé Nast Traveler. This is where you can enjoy the tranquil atmosphere. Besides, this is your starting point for unforgettable adventures in Key West. Wander around the lively Duval Street and explore the Old Town.

Welcome to a beautiful tropical place where the sun shines all year round. Head to the beach and watch the gorgeous sunset to end the busy day. Hyatt Centric Key West Resort & Spa offers a two-hour bike service for exploring the island. Besides, the staff can help you book a boat or a scooter.

All the bright and elegant rooms at Hyatt Centric Key West Resort & Spa come with a private balcony and fast Wi-Fi connection. Besides, you also have cable TV and a small fridge. Need more relaxation? Head to the Jala Spa to enjoy body wraps, facials, and massages.

Kimpton Lighthouse Hotel

1

Kimpton Lighthouse Hotel is truly the best boutique hotel in Key West. Sitting within walking distance from the iconic Key West Lighthouse and Hemingway’s home, this hotel places you in the center of the action. Besides, the hotel features a lively pool, bustling bar, and beautiful gardens where you get to create a magical moment and connect with fellow travelers.

There are many reasons why Kimpton Lighthouse Hotel is the best boutique hotel. In fact, this hotel covers half a city block. The building truly embodies Key West’s natural beauty and modern sophistication. Take a dip in the shimmering pool while sipping your favorite drink. There’s never a dull moment when you’re at Kimpton Lighthouse Hotel.

Now let’s talk about the rooms. Variety is the core of the hotel’s 45 guestrooms and 5 suites. Each one is designed individually, creating a unique character. The spacious rooms feature patios overlooking the botanical wonder. Here, you’ll discover a blend of 1800s architectural details and modern touches.

Recommended Restaurants/Bar in Key West

• Latitudes – This restaurant is part of Sunset key Cottages. It serves the most delicious island menu, the perfect spot for breakfast and lunch. The luxurious bar has an extensive list of beverages.
• Blue Heaven – If you’re looking for a unique restaurant in Key West, come to Blue Heaven. This restaurant has been around since 1992, and it’s still one of the most popular restaurants in Key West. Try the Caribbean BBQ shrimp, and you’ll be blown away.
• Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen – Enjoy American coastal comfort food at Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen. The fresh local ingredients are what makes the menu so good. Besides, you get to see the beautiful waterfront panorama while enjoying your meals.

Recommended Things To Do in Key West

• Reef Snorkel Morning Tour with Breakfast & Mimosas – Key West is about fun water activities. As you can guess from the tour’s name, this one is all about discovering the magic of underwater and enjoying a delicious breakfast.
• Key West Parasailing Flights – Fly high above the sky and see the beautiful panorama as free as a bird. Immerse yourself in the unique sensation and enjoy the ocean breeze.
• Key West Dolphin Watch and Snorkel Eco Tour – Imagine seeing cute dolphins as you snorkel in their habitat. Besides, you also get to witness the diversity of the flora and beautiful coral formations.

Where To Stay in Key West

The answer to where the best area to stay in Key West depends on your plan and travel style. If this is your first time in Key West, we recommend staying in the Duval Street area. This is the most famous street in the city, and it offers a vibrant atmosphere. You’ll find plenty of bars, cafes, restaurants and local shops here.

What if you come to Key West for its water adventures? In that case, you should stay in the Historic Seaport area. This neighborhood offers scenic ocean views and plenty of fun water activities. If you’re really into watersports, you will love it here.

Now, what about the local experience? If you’re one of those who love to live like a local, you should go to Bahama Village. This neighborhood is in the southern part of Key West. This is where you get to immerse yourself in the authentic local experience. So basically, all the best hotels in Key West can be found in any neighborhood in the city.