11 Best Hotels near Theater District NYC

New York City is such a culturally significant city. It’s the zeitgeist of our modern culture. Whether it’s fashion, music, lifestyle, arts, or basically anything that captured the world’s attention, you can mostly track it back down to New York City. And when talking about New York’s art scene, we (fortunately) can’t escape the influence Broadway has on the world. Having so many people who appreciate the art of theater performances flocking to the city, it’s only natural that there are plenty of best hotels near Theater District NYC.

With that, it can be quite overwhelming to choose from all the varying options. But we guarantee, our well-curated list will take care of that. You’ll just need to think about what shows you’ll want to see first, and make the most of your NYC trip! You can even check out our list of things to do in NYC if you don’t know where to start.

M Social Hotel Times Square New York 

11

Starting strong on our list with M Social Hotel Times Square New York. It’s located in the heart of the Theater District on Broadway Street. Broadway Theater literally just across the road, Neil Theater neighboring us, and other big theaters are just within walking distance. Beyond its perfect location, the hotel has the classic glam and sleek look to it, with a touch of mid-century modern aesthetics. Stepping into the lobby alone instantly made us feel like a sophisticated New Yorker.

Furthermore, the hotel’s hospitality and services match its attention to detail. The staff was always great from the moment we arrived, and after an electrifying day, we can always depend on them to help us relax. Not to mention, our room was the perfect haven amid the hustle and bustle of New York. The bed was extra comfy, we had all the necessary mod-cons, and our window looked out to Times Square. For convenience, the hotel has a fitness center, too. However, their restaurant, Beast & Butterflies, was another highlight of our stay. The food and service were amazing, and we got to sit on the outdoor terrace with Times Square as our view. The perfect cherry on top of our stay.

Hard Rock Hotel New York

10

On our many trips to NY, we just had to stay at Hard Rock Hotel New York once. It’s in the middle of Times Square, so it couldn’t get more New York than this. And nothing screams theatrical than the hotel’s rock and roll aesthetics. The hotel was like a museum of music. Aside from its modern interior design, most of its decor is memorabilia of famous musicians. Our trip to the Theater District couldn’t be more iconic than this.

”The Hard Hotel New York is practically part of the culture, it’s part of the New York experience that we just had to live ourselves.”

WOW Travel

That said, as a world-renowned hotel, we expected nothing but perfect hospitality and services from Hard Rock Hotel New York. Firstly, our room was excellent, it exuded comfort and warmth. Just what we need after a day of traversing busy New York. The staff also took extra care of us. They catered to our every need and gave us personalized services. Furthermore, while the area is brimming with restaurants, markets, bars, and gyms, having free access to the hotel’s gym and getting complimentary breakfast was convenient. Plus, the hotel’s terrace restaurant was our go-to place for dinner with a view of the city.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Hard Rock Hotel New York (@hardrockhotelnyc)

The Muse New York

9

Located on 47th Street, between 6th and 7th Ave, The Muse New York is practically steps away from all the iconic spots in Midtown. Both Broadway and Times Square are just at the end of the street, and so is the 5th Avenue Shopping Center. That said, while we had our full share of exploring New York, we could always count on the hotel to be our temporary home.

At this boutique hotel, we were provided with exemplary hospitality. They catered to all types of travelers. For theatergoers like us, the location was a big advantage, and the hotel’s decor was a feast for our eyes. Our room was well-appointed, pristine, and filled with great amenities. We particularly enjoyed lounging on the chaise beside the window. That aside, the hotel also offers connecting rooms, perfect for big groups or families, and pet-friendly rooms.

Moreover, the hotel also prides itself on its high-end fitness center, complete with Peloton bikes, and its award-winning Muse Bar. As for us, their complimentary bike rentals were our favorite feature. While we loved discovering New York on foot, riding bikes was a lot more convenient.

New York Marriott Marquis

8

Staying at the New York Marriott Marquis was a fancy and luxurious experience for us. We were thoroughly impressed by how attentive the staff were. Not to mention, the hotel itself was the image of luxury. From the moment we got there, the pristine lobby immediately set the tone of our stay. The staff warmly welcomed us and was quick to check us in. They also helped us settle in our room, which quickly became another highlight of our stay. Not only was it perfectly comfortable but the room also gave us a front-seat view of the bustling Times Square and Manhattan skyline.

That said, it’s undeniable that the hotel’s best feature is its location. It’s literally in the heart of Times Square, with Broadway Street just at our doorstep. We were spoiled with how easy it was to catch Broadway plays, especially since we could get tickets from the hotel’s concierge. Plus, the hotel’s Broadway Lounge is famous among theatergoers, and it easily became a hangout place before shows. Lastly, you can check this out for more of our extensive review of the best Marriot Hotels in NYC.

citizenM New York Times Square

7

The citizenM New York Times Square is the sort of hip and sophisticated New York hotel near the theater district that you’d expect. While the staff was quick to attend to us, we could easily move around the hotel with only a touch from our phone. From booking a room and checking in, all of it can be done from the hotel’s app.

That said, the hotel still has a communal vibe to it. For one, the lobby was designed like a living room, with curated knick-knacks, artworks, and plenty of seating area for us to hang out or read from the hotel’s huge book collection. We also particularly loved how the fitness center opens to the hotel terrace overlooking the city, and there was a communal kitchen that opens 24/7. Additionally, the hotel’s cloudM made the perfect place to unwind and enjoy NYC from a bird eye’s view.

Moreover, the guestrooms here are designed to make us feel relaxed and cocooned after a full respite to the city. The windows are soundproof, the blinds are blacked out, and the bed is fitted to the walls, creating the perfect sanctuary. The room is also fitted with lots of modern amenities. We were able to control the room’s mood light, blinds, and TV with a tablet provided in the room. Lastly, the details like streaming services on our TV, and the power shower in the bathroom, were extra tidbits that made our stay tons better.

Motto By Hilton New York City Times Square

6

Motto By Hilton New York City Times Square is a great hotel through and through. As part of the Hilton Hotel group, we weren’t worried about their hospitality and services. It was sublime from start to finish. The staff were excellent. Although, we did have to pay a few extra charges for internet, access to the fitness center, bike rents, and other necessities. But, the perfect location more than makes up for it. We were right in the heart of Midtown New York, with Broadway and the Theater District around the block.

That said, the Motto sports a fresher and more contemporary version of the usual Hilton Hotel. The decor choices definitely cater more to hip youngsters, with its compact interior and mid-century furnishing. Our room was also on the smaller side, but it was cozy and comfortable, with a great view of the city. For families, the hotel offers connecting rooms, so everyone can enjoy a night at Motto By Hilton New York City Times Square. Lastly, when we were not window shopping at 5th Ave, or cafe hopping around Times Square, the hotel’s bar made a great escape from the noise.

Ameritania at Times Square

5

Ameritania at Times Square is located in the middle of the Theater District, with Ed Sullivan Theater right beside the hotel, and Broadway Theater a road cross away. And with that, we’re also just steps away from Times Square, and under 10 minutes from Central Park. And for its ideal location, the hotel is relatively budget-friendly. Furthermore, the hotel’s iconic features don’t stop there. For starters, the hotel is housed in the historical Beaux-Arts building and sports a chic, art-deco interior that’s a complete 180 from its outdoor looks.

That said, the hotel is more than its perfect location and unique design choices. Their high-quality hospitality also ensured that we had an unforgettable stay. For one, the staff went above and beyond assisting us get a city-view room and recommending hole-in-the-wall bars. Secondly, we appreciate the extra freebies like complimentary coffee and acces to the fitness center. Lastly, as for our room, it was great. Like the rest of the hotel, our room was stylish, and had a retro vibe, with amenities like a cable TV, and coffee maker for extra convenience.

Romer Hell’s Kitchen

4

Best location. Romer Hell’s Kitchen is a hotel that celebrates the artistic nature of Hell’s Kitchen. Everything about the hotel is an homage to its neighborhood. From its eclectic and refreshing interior design to its corner shop with Hell’s Kitchen memorabilia. It’s the hotel that perfectly suits young Broadway enjoyers like us. Plus, the location put us conveniently close to many of the theaters, Carnegie Hall, and Radio City Music Hall, while not being directly in the middle of busy Time Squares.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Romer Hell’s Kitchen | New York City Hotel (@romerhellskitchen)

Moreover, the level of hospitality here is beyond. Every day the staff would give us new recommendations of hidden gems of the city. And while we loved exploring the area, staying in and enjoying the city from our well-appointed room was also a delight. We’d often have a half-day just lounging in the room watching TV, getting room services, or heading down to the hotel’s iconic bar for a drink.

CIVILIAN Hotel

3

Best interior design. Staying at the CIVILIAN Hotel was like having a glimpse of our lives as Broadway actors. The hotel is more than just a place for us to get back to after exploring New York, it’s also where the city’s creative minds and artists converge. From our guest room alone, it was apparent that this hotel is designed for thespians and guests who love a dramatic flair. While the room was a bit too compact for our taste, the velvet bed curtain and bold-colored walls added to the theatrical vibe of our stay. Everything was artfully designed, from the bathroom to the smallest details like golden-lined knobs, a functioning rotary phone, and other vintage knick-knacks.

Furthermore, housed in a building designed by the iconic David Rockwell, it’s no surprise that the rest of the hotel is as handsomely decorated. For starters, the lobby’s architecture is mostly exposed brick walls, giving us that authentic York living style. The four restaurants and bars were in our opinion the main stars of the hotel. Each one has different and unique decorations, with Broadway Blue, one of our faves, offering an experience of indulging crafted cocktails surrounded by hundreds of Broadway memorabilia.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by CIVILIAN Hotel (@civilianhotel)

Lastly, the Hell’s Kitchen location put us close to every iconic destination in NYC, and of course, the Theater District. On top of it, we wouldn’t have enjoyed our stay this much if it weren’t for the dedicated hotel staff. There’s a reason why a boutique hotel in NYC like the CIVILIAN Hotel has a 4-star rating and it wasn’t for its looks and location alone.

Millennium Premier New York Times Square

2

Best room view. The Millennium Premier New York Times Square is another hotel that we can vouch for providing a respite in the middle of Times Square. While we had the advantage of being steps away from Broadway, the area can be overwhelming. That said, stepping into the hotel always felt like an immediate refresh. The warm and friendly staff never failed to put a smile on our faces and the hotel’s simple and elegant decor wasn’t overstimulating.

Beyond that, the hotel’s services and hospitality had us satisfied throughout our stay. Our room, for one, was good and spacious. While having a plush bed, Netflix, and a couch was great, the floor-to-ceiling window easily became the spotlight of our room. With a view like that, it’s not hard to be comfortable. Additionally, while the location allowed us to easily get breakfast, being offered free ones is always nice. Plus, we also had access to the hotel’s gym.

Aura Hotel Times Square

1

Overall Best. When staying in the city that never sleeps, we needed a hotel like Aura Hotel Times Square which offers a space to recharge and rejuvenate. The hotel is specifically designed to make us feel tranquil and serene from the moment we step into the lobby. Its warm tone color and soothing decor never failed to help us find our zen back and let the noise fade away.

Furthermore, the staff also helped a lot in maintaining the relaxing atmosphere. They were always ready to assist us with anything and were quick to check us in. Other than having access to the fitness center, our room also had an array of amazing amenities. We especially loved the Nespresso machine and luxury bath products. The bed was also incridible comfy, and the TV was a nice entertainment.

That said, the location was beyond convenient. We were on 120 W 44th St, so the Theater District and Times Square are just down the street. Additionally, Hudson Theater is right across from the hotel, and Bryant Park is just a short walk away. Overall, with all the great features we get at Aura Hotel Times Square, it’s easy to see them as one of the best hotels near Theater District NYC.

Our Verdict!

All New York hotels near Broadway theaters on this list are amazing, but some truly made their mark on us, especially Aura Hotel Times Square. With how exciting NYC can be, having a quiet getaway like the Aura Hotel hits differently. Beyond that, we do have other hotels that we’d like to highlight with features you might look for in your ideal hotel.

• Best location: Romer Hell’s Kitchen
• Best view: Millennium Premier New York Times Square
• Best interior design: CIVILIAN Hotel

Where to Stay in Theater District NYC?

Home to the world-renowned Broadway Street and the artistic pursuit of the theaters, it’s no wonder that New York has a dedicated Theater District in the heart of the city. Spanning from  West 41st to West 54th Streets, and from 6th to 8th Avenues, the Theater District touches most of Midtown Manhattan and Hell’s Kitchen. Most of the iconic tourist spots of New York are concentrated in these areas, making it packed and busy. Spots like Times Square, Carnegie Hall, Central Park, and Broadway Street itself.

For us, the constant buzz is part of the New York experience. That’s why we considered Midtown, and especially near Times Square as one of the best places to stay near the Theater District. It places us right in the heart of the city, with the theaters usually just a block or two away. Even sometimes just across the street.

Furthermore, the same goes for Hell’s Kitchen. Although, being just a few streets and blocks away from Times Square makes quite the difference. We did have to do more walking to get to the theaters. But everyone travels by foot in New York. Either that, or we take the train. That said, Hell’s Kitchen is more low-key and has more cozy restaurants, eclectic theaters, drag shows, and jazz clubs.

Lastly, New York City is very walkable and the train makes it easy to travel around. So, it all comes down to your preference and itinerary. Whichever area you choose to stay in, you can rest assured that we only have the best hotels near Theater District NYC on this list. And if you decide to come back to New York, you might wanna check out the best cheap hotels in New York City. 

What is considered the theatre district in NYC?

Most people equate the Theater District to Times Square because big theaters like Broadway and Minskoff Theater are in Times Square. But it really starts approximately from West 41st to West 54th Streets, and from 6th to 8th Avenues, with plenty of theaters strewn all over those areas.

What is the largest theater in NYC?

With approximately 1,900 seats, the Gershwin is the largest theater in NYC. It’s located at 221 West 51st Street.

Which theater is the Lion King show playing at?

Lion King is performed at the Minskoff Theater in Times Square. The show plays on Monday-Sunday.