11 Best Hotels Near Duval Street Key West

It’s hard not to be captivated by Key West’s laid-back atmosphere, stunning beaches, and lively nightlife. At the heart of this enchanting island is Duval Street, a bustling hub of entertainment, shopping, and dining. Based on our previous trips, we can confidently say that staying on Duval Street is always a good call. It offered us an immersive experience, and there were so many accommodations for us to consider. Today, we want to show you our favorite hotels near Duval Street Key West. The following hotels combine the convenience of easy access to the action with the peace and comfort of a secluded retreat. From boutique charm to budget-friendly options, this post will help you find the perfect hotel to enhance your Key West getaway.

Hyatt Centric Key West Resort & Spa

11

Kicking off this list is the Hyatt Centric Key West Resort & Spa, a paradise in Key West. This waterfront gem offers everything you could want for a relaxing and adventurous vacation. Let’s start with our King Room. Entering our cozy room with its private balcony, we knew we were in for a treat. The free Wi-Fi was a bonus, and the little fridge came in handy for storing our favorite drinks. The bed was incredibly comfortable, and we loved waking up to the stunning views, too.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Key West Florida Resort (@hyattcentrickw)

During our stay, we couldn’t resist indulging in some pampering at the on-site Jala Spa. The selection of treatments was impressive, and we both left feeling refreshed and rejuvenated. After our spa day, we hit the fitness center to burn off some energy. The resort’s pool and hot tub were the perfect places to unwind. We also took advantage of the water sports options and had a blast jet skiing and snorkeling. Hungry? We loved the convenience of having two restaurants right there at the resort. Shor American Seafood Grill satisfied our cravings for fresh seafood, while Blue Mojito Pool Bar and Grill was great for casual bites and refreshing drinks.

The Almond Tree Inn

10

Say hello to The Almond Tree Inn! This charming, low-rise motel is an absolute gem. The tropical garden creates such a relaxing atmosphere, and it’s incredibly convenient being just a short walk from the heart of Duval Street with its shops and restaurants. We stayed in the King Suite and it was both stylish and cozy. It came with a private porch that was perfect for morning coffee. Speaking of which, we also appreciated the little extras like the coffeemaker, microwave, and minifridge.

We enjoyed starting our days with the complimentary continental breakfast and winding down with the happy hour refreshments. The heated pool and hot tub were so inviting, especially after exploring Key West. Plus, we loved relaxing by the koi pond. It was a perfect escape!

Winslow’s Bungalows

9

Best Pet-Friendly. Winslow’s Bungalows is one of the most unique hotels around Duval Street Key West. The place drips with classic Key West charm, and it’s clear that this isn’t just a hotel – it’s a piece of history. We loved how it felt more like staying at a friend’s house than a typical hotel. When we arrived, we were startled. Multiple pools, including a heated one, invited us to relax, and there were plenty of cozy spots to curl up with a book or simply soak up the sunshine. We spent hours lounging in the hammocks, watching the world go by.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Key West Historic Inns (@keywesthistoricinns)

Also, let’s appreciate the fact that Winslow’s is pet-friendly. However, it’s worth noting that there’s a nightly fee per pet. It’s a small price to pay to bring your furry friend to paradise, but it’s something to keep in mind. Regarding the rooms, we highly recommend booking the King Suite. It’s huge and comes with a private patio. On top of that, we were fascinated by the history of the place. Winslow’s is one of Key West’s oldest homes and lodging, dating back to 1856! Ask the friendly staff for a quick history lesson. It’s worth it.

The Saint Hotel Key West

8

The Saint Hotel Key West is a great choice for those searching for stays by Duval Street. Located just a short stroll from quite literally everything, we loved being able to easily immerse ourselves in the local culture, shopping, and dining. The Ernest Hemingway House and the beautiful Smathers Beach are also within comfortable walking distance, making this hotel an ideal spot to explore the island.

We truly enjoyed staying in the double room. It was a stylish retreat with modern amenities like free Wi-Fi, a flat-screen TV, and others. We appreciated the sleek design featuring blue LED lighting and wood paneling. While the standard rooms were comfortable, those looking for a touch of luxury might want to consider upgrading to a suite with its vaulted ceilings and spacious sitting area. Some suites even offer kitchenettes and balconies for added comfort. Meanwhile, the hotel’s Creole restaurant and bar provided us with a cozy atmosphere to unwind. We also enjoyed relaxing by the pool with its refreshing waterfall.

Truman Hotel

7

Another awesome addition to this list of the best stays near Duval Street is the Truman Hotel. Let’s talk location first. It’s incredible! Being right in the heart of Key West’s historic district felt like stepping back in time but with all the modern conveniences. We were just a short stroll from Duval Street, where the energy is electric, but the hotel itself offered a peaceful oasis. Plus, having parking on-site was a huge bonus in this busy town.

Our room was everything we wanted. The bold colors and funky furniture gave it such a vibrant personality. We were obsessed with the zebra rugs and modern lighting. The bed was cloud-like, and the bathroom was pure luxury with its sleek tile and spacious shower. But the real highlight was the balcony. It was the perfect spot to unwind with a drink and soak up the Key West atmosphere. The pool area is another standout. It’s the ideal place to relax and soak up some sun. The lush surroundings create such a tropical vibe. We loved spending lazy afternoons there, catching up with friends.

For our full review, here is “Truman Hotel in Key West: A Gorgeous Boutique Hotel“.

The Marquesa Hotel

6

Best Adults-Only. We stepped into the Marquesa Hotel feeling like we were walking through a living history book. Built way back in 1884, this place has seen it all – from a bustling boarding house to a glamorous boutique hotel in Key West. And let’s not forget the celebrity connections! This place has hosted everyone from James Bond actors to renowned authors. Also, this hotel’s location is pure gold. Being right in the heart of Old Town Key West, we were surrounded by lively Duval Street while still enjoying a peaceful retreat. It’s the perfect base for exploring the island. We were pleasantly surprised by how close the airport was too – a quick and easy transfer.

We were spoiled for choice when it came to accommodations. Our suite was an oasis with two private terraces. The staff was incredibly helpful in guiding us to the perfect room, and we couldn’t be happier with our choice. If you’re looking for the best Key West hotel suites near Duval Street, this might be it. Café Marquesa, the hotel’s restaurant, also exceeded our expectations. The Southern-inspired dishes were delicious, and the atmosphere was charming. Breakfast was a simple yet satisfying buffet, with those incredible croissants being a standout. Best of all, the hotel offers not one, but three pools across its two locations. It’s the perfect way to unwind and soak up the Key West sun.

Read our full review of this hotel Marquesa Hotel in Key West: Experiencing Luxury!

Pier House Resort & Spa

5

Our stay at the Pier House Resort & Spa is hard to top. As a legendary hotspot for the creative crowd back in the ‘70s, we had high expectations. And let us tell you, they were exceeded. This place is a sprawling oasis right on the water, offering something for everyone. The spa was a highlight – we indulged in treatments that left us feeling refreshed and rejuvenated. And let’s not forget the dining options! The food was fantastic, and we couldn’t resist trying the bar where Jimmy Buffet himself got his start.

Furthermore, our room had that classic Old Florida charm with plenty of rattan, but we upgraded to a suite with a private patio. Watching Key West sunsets from there was truly an experience. Our bed was super comfy, and the amenities were top-notch. Pier House is perfectly located in the heart of the action, but once you’re on the property, it feels like a world away from the Duval Street hustle and bustle. We can’t wait to come back!

The Mansion on the Sea

4

Best Beachfront. Those looking for beachfront hotels in Key West near Duval Street should consider The Mansion on the Sea. We still can’t believe our luck! Staying at this beachfront hotel was an absolute dream. This sea foam green and pink Victorian beauty is like something out of a fairytale. The minute we stepped inside, we were transported to another era. The lobby is a treasure trove of history, with artifacts and memorabilia scattered everywhere. We spent ages ogling at Thomas Edison’s phonograph! It’s incredible to think that this place has hosted such legendary figures as Hemingway, Bernstein, and JFK.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by The Mansion on the Sea (@themansiononthesea)

Moreover, our room was pure indulgence. Every detail was carefully considered, from the four-poster bed to the original artwork. It felt like staying in a private suite. And the best part? Each room has its unique charm. We could happily spend our entire vacation exploring the different styles. Also, the infinity pool is an oasis of calm. We loved lounging on the hammocks and sipping cocktails from the poolside bar. The lobster pizza was unexpectedly amazing, too! And let’s not forget the complimentary continental breakfast.

Speaking of which, here are the best beachfront hotels in Key West!

NYAH

3

Up next is NYAH, a charming escape to Old Key West. If you’re wondering, it stands for “Not Your Average Hotel”, and it lives up to the hype. Imagine a cluster of adorable conch cottages with tin roofs and white balconies – that’s NYAH. The rooms might be no-frills, but they’re clean, functional, and surprisingly comfortable. We loved the bunk beds – they were great for groups and surprisingly comfy. Each bed even has its own night light and charging station, which is a nice touch. Plus, the private bathrooms, mini-fridges, and individual lockers were super convenient.

The real star of the show is the central courtyard. It’s a red brick oasis with three sparkling pools and a hot tub surrounded by lush greenery. It was our favorite place to relax and feel the sun. Location-wise, NYAH is fantastic. It’s just a short stroll from the Historic Seaport and Duval Street, but the neighborhood itself is charming with its pastel cottages and cute little shops. We felt like we were experiencing the authentic Key West vibe.

“While not the fanciest, NYAH certainly offers a great value for the money.”

WOW Travel

Opal Key Resort & Marina

2

Best Amenities. If you’re all about soaking up those golden hour vibes and experiencing the full waterfront resort life, Opal Key Resort & Marina is your Key West calling. We’re talking about a prime spot at the mouth of Key West Harbor, where the resort’s promenade flows seamlessly into the lively Mallory Square. Imagine watching the sun paint the sky in hues of orange and pink while surrounded by street performers and the local charm.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Opal Key Resort & Marina (@opalkeyresortmarina)

This resort is a dream. We loved lounging by the courtyard pool, enjoying waterfront dining with our toes in the sand, and capping off the day with sunset cocktails at the rooftop bar. But let’s talk about the real star of the show: the marina. It’s your gateway to unforgettable water adventures! Snorkeling, parasailing, sunset sailing, fishing charters – you name it. When it came to the accommodation, we stayed in a spacious room with a balcony overlooking the harbor. And with Duval Street’s vibrant nightlife, dining, and entertainment just a block away, Opal Key offers the perfect balance of relaxation and excitement.

Ocean Key Resort & Spa

1

Best Luxury. The Ocean Key Resort & Spa is the epitome of Key West luxury. Nestled right at the foot of Duval Street, with the harbor as its backdrop, this place is pure magic. During our stay, we were always captivated by the pool with its incredible shade of blue that rivals the ocean. We also adored the Sunset Pier bar – the perfect spot to watch the sun dip below the horizon with a cocktail in hand. SpaTerre, the resort’s on-site sanctuary, is an absolute must-visit. We indulged in a heavenly Balinese massage followed by a rejuvenating flower petal bath. Meanwhile, Hot Tin Roof, the resort’s signature restaurant, elevated our taste buds with its innovative take on Floribbean cuisine. The seared black grouper in coconut curry was a standout.

We were equally impressed with the resort’s breezy beach house aesthetic. Polished limestone floors, rustic wood-paneled ceilings, and cool-toned furnishings created a relaxed and inviting atmosphere. And the cherry on top? Every room here boasts a private balcony with stunning harbor views. It’s the perfect place to sip morning coffee or enjoy a glass of wine as the sun sets.

For other similar hotels, check out these best luxury hotels in Key West, Florida!

Our Verdict!

You can’t go wrong with the hotels above. Still, which one suits you best? To help you out, we’ve categorized some of them based on the following.

• Best Luxury: Ocean Key Resort & Spa
• Best Amenities: Opal Key Resort & Marina
• Best Beachfront: The Mansion on the Sea
• Best Adults-Only: The Marquesa Hotel
• Best Pet-Friendly: Winslow’s Bungalows

Where to Stay Near Duval Street Key West?

One of Key West’s most popular neighborhoods is Old Town. This is the heart of Key West and home to Duval Street, so staying here puts you right in the middle of the action. You’ll be within walking distance of all the best restaurants, bars, shops, and attractions.

Then, there’s New Town, an area just north of Old Town. This place offers a quieter and more residential experience compared to the bustling Old Town. It’s a mix of local homes, apartment buildings, and some commercial areas. While it might not have the same level of tourist attractions, it provides a more authentic glimpse into Key West life.

Also, there’s Bahama Village. South of Old Town, this is a vibrant neighborhood with a rich history and a strong cultural identity. It’s known for its colorful buildings, local art scene, and a relaxed atmosphere. There are diverse dining and entertainment options, too.

Is Duval Street close to the beach?

Yes, it is. South Beach, the closest beach, is at the southern end of the street. It’s within walking distance of many Duval Street attractions.

Is Duval Street in Old Town?

Yes, Duval Street is the main thoroughfare of Old Town Key West. It’s famous for its vibrant atmosphere, shops, restaurants, and nightlife.

What do you wear to Duval Street?

Duval Street is known for its casual atmosphere, so opt for comfortable clothing like shorts, t-shirts, and flip-flops.