The Best Kosher Hotels in New York City

New York City is a culinary melting pot, with a diverse range of dining options to suit every palate. Even seasoned Empire City explorers like us still find new tastes to tantalize our taste buds. Yet, for kosher travelers, finding a hotel that aligns with their dietary restrictions can be a daunting task. That’s where we come in! Below, you’ll find the best Kosher hotels in New York City. While options may be limited, these three hotels surely will make your trip a lot easier and more enjoyable. Thanks to them, you can have a comfortable stay without compromising your dietary needs. So, scroll down and explore your kosher haven in the Big Apple!

What Is a Kosher Hotel?

Kosher is a set of dietary laws practiced by Jewish people. These laws specify which foods are considered acceptable to eat and how those foods must be prepared. The term “kosher” comes from the Hebrew word “kasher”, which means “fit” or “proper”.

So, a kosher hotel is a hotel that strictly adheres to Jewish dietary laws. This includes avoiding pork, shellfish, and certain combinations of meat and dairy. Examples of kosher dishes you might find at a hotel include omelets, cereals, salads, sandwiches, and even vegan dishes.

Aside from that, Kosher hotels often have separate kitchens for preparing meat and dairy dishes to prevent contamination. Many kosher hotels are also certified by recognized kosher certification organizations to ensure compliance with Jewish dietary laws.

Sleepy Hollow Hotel

3

Best Amenities. The Sleepy Hollow Hotel is located in Tarrytown, a northern suburb of New York City. When we first arrived, we were immediately captivated by the hotel’s traditional façade and elegant style. Not to mention, it’s located in a resort-like setting, making our stay feel even more exclusive.

We were also impressed by the inclusivity of this hotel and its commitment to accommodating Jewish travelers’ dietary needs. Aside from the classic American breakfast, the on-site restaurant also offers a variety of delicious kosher options, from the a la carte breakfast to the special Shabbos package. The all-inclusive Shabbos package is especially convenient, providing guests with all the meals they need, as well as access to separate swim hours for men and women and a beautiful property enclosed by an eiruv.

Beyond the kosher amenities, the hotel offered a host of other features that made our stay enjoyable. The pool, sauna, and fitness center were perfect for relaxing and staying active. The staff was friendly and attentive, always ready to assist with our needs. We also adored our Standard King Room. It was big enough for the two of us and had everything we needed, plus a beautiful view of the garden.

The Avenue Plaza

2

Best Luxury. This list won’t be complete without The Avenue Plaza. One of the major things that drew us in was its prime location in the middle of Jewish communal life, Borough Park. The neighborhood is a bustling hub of activity, with synagogues, Jewish stores, and the vibrant energy of the community at every turn.

Speaking of which, you’ll appreciate the food here. The selection of kosher foods was impressive, and everything was fresh and delicious. We particularly enjoyed the well-done hashbrowns, eggs cooked to perfection, and variety of cheeses. The dining area itself was more modern than we expected, creating a pleasant atmosphere to start the day. Also, have we mentioned that the kosher breakfast is free?

Now, The Avenue Plaza offers a wide range of accommodations. Since we wanted something a little fancy, we went with the Luxury Room. The spacious layout, elegant decor, and comfortable amenities made us feel right at home. The two full-size beds were incredibly comfortable, and the open balcony gave us a lovely view of the bustling city below. The room was also equipped with a kitchenette, so we could cook whatever we wanted.

“Inclusive, luxurious, and beautiful, The Avenue Plaza sure is one of the top hotels in Borough Park.”

WOW Travel

Park House Hotel Brooklyn

1

Best Value for Money. When it comes to the best Kosher hotels in NYC, the Park House Hotel Brooklyn should be on the top of this list as it checks all the right boxes. First of all, this hotel is set in the heart of Borough Park. Staying in this neighborhood, known for its large Orthodox Jewish community, we could find a wealth of kosher dining options in the vicinity. We loved the vibrant atmosphere, and getting around was a breeze as the nearest subway stop was only two blocks away.

For our stay, we booked the one-bedroom studio. It was spacious and well-appointed, with two full-sized beds, a kitchen area, and a full bathroom. The room was meticulously designed with both function and style in mind, and we loved every space in our studio. The fact that in-room Shabbos meals were available was a huge plus for us, too.

One of the highlights of our stay was the free kosher breakfast buffet. Every day except Saturday, guests can enjoy a delicious spread of made-to-order omelets, fresh baked goods, gourmet cheeses, dips, salads, and more. We didn’t expect the breakfast to be that good. When we arrived at the dining area, we were immediately hypnotized by the aroma of freshly baked bread. The combination of its convenient location, comfortable accommodations, and delicious kosher breakfast made the hotel a great choice for our trip to Borough Park.

For more accommodations in the area, check out these best hourly hotels in Brooklyn and these best hostels in Brooklyn!

Our Verdict!

All of the Kosher hotels in New York City listed above are equally amazing. Yet, they have their own unique offerings that appeal to different travelers. To help you pick the right hotel, we’ve categorized them into the following:

• Best Value for Money: Park House Hotel Brooklyn
• Best Luxury: The Avenue Plaza
• Best Amenities: Sleepy Hollow Hotel

Where to Stay in New York City for Kosher Travelers

When it comes to kosher hotels in NYC, there’s only one place to be, and that’s Borough Park. It’s a vibrant neighborhood in Brooklyn, New York, renowned for its large Orthodox Jewish community. It’s a cultural hub where tradition meets modernity, offering a unique and immersive experience for visitors.

Borough Park boasts a plethora of kosher restaurants, bakeries, and delis, serving a wide variety of delicious and authentic Jewish cuisine. From traditional challah bread and matzo ball soup to modern fusion dishes, you’ll find something to satisfy every palate.

The neighborhood is also home to numerous synagogues and community centers, where you can witness religious services, participate in cultural events, and connect with the local community. Some of the popular synagogues are the Young Israel Beth El of Boro Park and Khal Beis Yaakov Burshtin Shul.

Other notable areas include Crown Heights, and the Upper East and West Sides. These areas are home to a huge Jewish population, and you can find several kosher restaurants there. For hotel recommendations, take a look at these best hotels in the Upper East Side and Upper West Side!

What makes a hotel kosher?

A hotel is considered kosher if it adheres to strict Jewish dietary laws, such as separating meat and dairy, using only kosher ingredients, and ensuring all food is prepared and served under the supervision of a certified rabbi.

Why are kosher rules so strict?

Kosher rules are strict to ensure purity and separation from non-kosher foods. This is rooted in religious beliefs about the sanctity of life and the importance of following God’s laws.

Is a cheeseburger kosher?

No, cheeseburgers are not kosher. This is because Kosher law prohibits the consumption of meat and dairy products together. Cheese is a dairy product, and cheeseburgers contain beef, a meat product. Therefore, the combination of meat and dairy in a cheeseburger makes it non-kosher.