11 Best Boutique Hotels in Nantucket

Nantucket, Massachusets, has been a famous holiday vacation for many years. With its historic whaling town background combined with its scenic and eclectic neighborhoods, Nantucket is worth every hype it gets. Located south of Cape Cod, Nantucket offers a fantastic getaway with historical buildings, quaint restaurants, and luxurious shopping strips. Another way you can enjoy this stunning island is by strolling through the lovely beaches and visiting the many famous lighthouses on the island. You can even go fishing with a local guide if you want to!

That said, one thing about Nantucket is its determination to preserve the historical beauty of its town. Everywhere you look, you can see locally-owned accommodations and vintage mansions dating from the 1800s. And lucky for you, we have carefully curated all the best boutique hotels in Nantucket that are housed in these beautiful historical buildings! Just scroll down some more and find the best one for you.

Martin House Inn

11

The Martin House Inn in Nantucket is a splendid and elegant boutique hotel that has captured the hearts of travelers for years. It’s classic New England architecture, spacious rooms, and period antiques reflect the inn’s history and character. With only several guest rooms, the Martin House Inn offers an intimate and personalized experience that larger hotels cannot match. Each room is uniquely decorated with plush bedding, vintage furnishings, and upscale amenities. The inn also offers a delicious homemade breakfast, afternoon tea, and evening wine and cheese reception, making it the perfect choice for a romantic getaway or a relaxing retreat.

In addition to its cozy and comfortable accommodations, the Martin House Inn also boasts an ideal location in Nantucket’s historic district. Guests can easily walk to nearby shops, restaurants, and attractions or take a short bike ride to explore the island’s natural beauty. Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a regular to Nantucket, the Martin House Inn is sure to exceed your expectations as one of the best boutique hotels in Nantucket.

76 Main

10

Best value for money. The quaint and stylish 76 Main is one of the top boutique hotels in Nantucket. This hotel is a favorite among travelers looking for a unique and intimate experience on this idyllic island because of its impeccable style and top-notch amenities. From the moment you step into the hotel’s elegant lobby, you’re transported to a world of comfort and sophistication. You’ll find refreshing and bright decor around the hotel, bringing out the island’s cheery vibe. Each hotel’s guest room is tastefully decorated with designer furnishings and classy linens. You can easily feel peaceful and carefree while staying here.

Furthermore, 76 Main also offers a variety of amenities designed to make you feel pampered and relaxed. These include a full-service spa, a fitness center, a cozy backyard, and a gourmet continental breakfast served each morning. Other than that, thanks to the hotel’s amazing location, you can easily explore the attractions, including beaches, museums, and markets. So really, we can’t recommend you enough to check out the 76 Main.

Jared Coffin House

9

As one of Nantucket’s most historic hotels, Jared Coffin House embodies the spirit of the former whaling town, providing charming accommodations along with an array of modern conveniences. At this hotel, you can enjoy the classic elegance of a historic mansion-turned-hotel, where you’ll feel at ease in beautiful guestrooms and relaxed common areas. Having beautifully restored, the rooms at the Jared Coffin House are spacious and tastefully decorated. Each room is equipped with fine amenities, including a cable TV and free Wi-Fi. You can even select from a variety of room types, including standard rooms, deluxe rooms, and suites, each with its own distinct personality.

That aside, one of the best features of the Jared Coffin House is its central location, steps away from Nantucket’s top restaurants, shops, and attractions. You can easily explore the island’s stunning beaches, gorgeous neighborhoods, and historical landmarks. All in all, as far as boutique hotels in Nantucket go, the Jared Coffin House is for sure one of the ones you should check out.

Seven Sea Street Inn

8

If you’re looking for boutique hotels in Nantucket, then look no further than the Seven Sea Street Inn. Located on a quiet street in the historic district of Nantucket, this hotel promises a truly serene bed & breakfast experience. The Inn boasts finely decorated rooms and suites, each furnished with antique furniture, luxurious linens, and modern amenities. What’s even great is you can choose from accommodations with fireplaces, soaking tubs, private decks, and stunning harbor views.

Furthermore, the hotel’s welcoming ambiance extends to the common areas, where guests can relax in the cozy library or enjoy a complimentary breakfast in the sunny dining room. In addition, the hotel’s beautifully landscaped gardens offer a tranquil retreat from the hustle and bustle of the island. Seven Sea Street Inn’s prime location places guests within walking distance of Nantucket’s top restaurants, boutiques, and beaches. The attentive staff provides personalized service to ensure a memorable stay. With its historic charm and modern amenities, Seven Sea Street Inn is one of the best boutique hotels in Nantucket.

Hotel Pippa

7

Hotel Pippa is the ideal boutique hotel for those seeking an intimate, cozy stay on the picturesque island of Nantucket. Firstly, this beautiful inn is located in the heart of downtown, steps from the best restaurants, shops, and the historic Whaling Museum. 

Secondly, the guestrooms here are so beautiful and comfortable that you won’t want to leave Nantucket. Each room is beautifully decorated with a unique style, ranging from classic coastal to modern bohemian. And the blue accents scattered around the room and the hotel pair perfectly with Nantucket’s breezy atmosphere. The hotel also offers amenities such as a daily continental breakfast, complimentary bicycles, and a cozy outdoor fire pit.

Thirdly, on top of having all the qualities befitting of great boutique hotels in Nantucket, Hotel Pippa also ensures exceptional service. The staff here are ready to help you with anything and will make sure all of your needs are taken care of.

Cliff Lodge Nantucket

6

Cliff Lodge Nantucket is a stunning boutique hotel that is one of the best places to stay in Nantucket. Located in the scenic Sconset Village, the hotel boasts a stunning setting with panoramic views of the Atlantic Ocean. This historic hotel has been gracefully renovated and now offers elegant and luxurious accommodations with modern amenities. Each room is unique, with comfortable beds, lovely furnishings, and original artwork. Staying here, you’ll feel pampered and relaxed thanks to the hotel’s exceptional service and attention to detail.

In addition to that, the Cliff Lodge Nantucket also offers a range of amenities. Every morning, you can enjoy a delicious breakfast while relaxing in the hotel’s beautiful garden or hang out on the rooftop deck and take in the breathtaking view. Furthermore, the hotel’s prime location also provides easy access to the island’s top attractions. Places like the Sconset Bluff Walk, the Sankaty Head Lighthouse, and lovely shops and restaurants are just a few steps away. Overall, as one of the famous boutique hotels in Nantucket, the Cliff Lodge doesn’t disappoint.

Brass Lantern Inn

5

The Brass Lantern Inn is a captivating boutique hotel located in downtown Nantucket. The inn’s quaint and cozy atmosphere has made it a favorite among travelers looking for a peaceful and relaxing getaway. The inn has 17 distinct guest rooms, all of which are tastefully decorated with antiques and comfortable furnishings. Rooms range in size and style from cozy and intimate to spacious and luxurious.

In addition to its inviting guest rooms, the Brass Lantern Inn offers exceptional amenities and services. Guests can enjoy a delicious homemade breakfast each morning and complimentary afternoon tea and freshly baked cookies. The inn also features a lovely outdoor patio and garden area, perfect for relaxing and enjoying the beautiful Nantucket weather. Other than that, The Brass Lantern Inn also has an excellent location. You’re within walking distance of Nantucket’s many attractions by staying here. You’ll find historical landmarks, quaint shops, and top-rated restaurants just around the area. 

With its warm and welcoming ambiance, exceptional amenities, and prime location, it’s no wonder that the Brass Lantern Inn is considered one of the best boutique hotels in Nantucket.

White Elephant Nantucket

4

Best hotels for couples. White Elephant, located in Nantucket’s charming downtown area, is a luxurious boutique hotel that provides its guests with a one-of-a-kind and unforgettable experience. With its classic New England-style architecture, stunning harbor views, and exceptional service, it’s only fair that we include White Elephant on our list of the best boutique hotels in Nantucket. 

With that said, each of the hotel’s rooms and suites is elegantly appointed with luxurious amenities, including Frette linens, plush robes, and Molton Brown bath products. The hotel’s strategic location puts guests just steps away from the island’s best shopping, dining, and attractions. You can easily visit places such as the Nantucket Whaling Museum and Brant Point Lighthouse.

Furthermore, their award-winning restaurant, Brant Point Grill, offers a menu of fresh seafood and local ingredients, while their spa provides a range of relaxing treatments. So, all in all, White Elephant is an ideal place to stay when visiting Nantucket for a romantic getaway or a family vacation.

Life House Nantucket

3

Best room. Located in downtown Nantucket, the Life House Nantucket is a beautifully restored 1830s mansion with stylish decor and sleek facilities. So not only that, the hotel is pleasing to the eye you can also easily reach the best local restaurants, shopping, and going to beaches from the hotel.

Having said that, accommodation-wise, each hotel room has its own flair and character. The rooms are designed to meet guests’ preferences, from cozy single rooms to spacious suites. Plus, the amenities include fancy products like La Labo toiletries, Marshall speakers, and Revival NY linens.

Furthermore, when it comes to the facilities, the hotel ensures that you can enjoy Nantucket’s fresh atmosphere to the fullest. There’s a cozy library, charming outdoor spaces, and a rooftop bar with stunning views of the island. Guests can also enjoy a complimentary continental breakfast each morning, and beach cruisers to explore the island at their leisure.

Overall, considering the lengths that Life House Nantucket takes to become one of the top boutique hotels in Nantucket, it’ll be a loss if you don’t check them out.

Greydon House Nantucket

2

Best interior design. The Greydon House is one of the best boutique hotels in Nantucket, built in the 1800s. Located in the Downtown area, this hotel seamlessly provides luxurious benefits while still preserving the vintage and historic feel of the building. Only in the Greydon House is where you’ll discover artworks by Terry Winters, an overgrown English garden, and a whimsical Venetian-inspired restaurant. 

The hotel’s luxury also extends to the amenities that are offered to its guestroom. For starters, the beds and lighting fixtures are custom designed by Roman and Williams. The bathrooms have Waterworks brass fixtures, Acqua di Parma bath products, and hand-painted nautical scenes on the bathroom tiles in Portugal. 

Furthermore, the hotel’s ideal location gives you easy access to many of Nantucket’s famous attractions. You can bike to ‘Sconset, enjoy the after-beach scene at Cisco Brewery, and walk the island’s interior’s conserved moors. You can even ask the staff to give you tips on the island’s hidden treasures. 

Blue Iris by Life House

1

Nestled in the heart of Nantucket Island, Blue Iris by Life House is a stunning boutique hotel that exudes elegance, charm, and sophistication. Whether you’re looking to relax in your room or explore the charming streets of Nantucket, Blue Iris by Life House has everything you need to make your trip truly special. This beautiful hotel boasts 12 uniquely designed guest rooms. Inspired by an art collector, each room is adorned with layered and patterned textiles, rustic Mediterranean elements, and antique wood details influenced by Portuguese design.

Staying here, you can enjoy a delicious breakfast in the beautiful garden courtyard or take a stroll to nearby attractions like the Whaling Museum or the famous Brant Point Lighthouse. Every guest also has full access to the nearby beachside club pool. Plus, you can use the hotel’s complimentary beach shuttle service and beach gear rentals to make your trip more convenient. All in all, it’ll be a huge loss not to book a room here!

Our Verdict!

From this list, you can already see that the Blue iris by Life House is the all-around best boutique hotel in Nantucket. Having said that, we also have made a highlight of hotels with some features that you might look for in a boutique hotel:

• Best value for money: 76 Main
• Best room: Life House Nantucket
• Best hotels for couples: White Elephant Nantucket
• Best interior design: Greydon House Nantucket

Where to Stay in Nantucket

Nantucket is a lovely island with a variety of neighborhoods, each with its own distinct personality and charm. Choosing which area to stay in depends highly on your preferences and interests. With that said, there are mainly three neighborhoods that draw tourists the most. There’s the downtown area, Brant Point, and the Sconset.

For starters, the Downtown area is probably the most convenient place to look for historic boutique hotels in Nantucket. With its cobblestone streets, historic buildings, and picturesque harbor, the Downtown area is practically Nantucket’s heart. Staying downtown puts you close to restaurants, shops, and attractions such as the Whaling Museum and the Atheneum.

Brant Point it’s located on the eastern edge of the island. Here you’ll find a scenic and upscale neighborhood with stunning ocean views and easy access to the beach. It’s also home to the Brant Point Lighthouse, one of Nantucket’s most iconic landmarks. Last but not least, the Sconset is known for its stunning village with quaint cottages, rose-covered trellises, and a scenic bluff walk along the ocean. It’s a quieter and more secluded neighborhood than downtown, but it still has plenty of restaurants, shops, and attractions.

Overall, Nantucket is a fairly small island. So no matter where you stay, you’ll still be able to easily explore many of its neighborhoods, restaurants, and beaches. Don’t forget to pack your best travel-friendly clothes and have the best of times in Nantucket!

How many days should you stay in Nantucket?

4 days on Nantucket is the ideal amount of time to get a feel for the island and experience everything it offers. Of course, longer is preferable, but fewer days are also feasible.

What is the nicest beach on Nantucket?

Surfside Beach is one of Nantucket’s most popular beaches. Although the surf can be rough at times, it is still ideal for families. Surfers can occasionally be found here, and the waves are usually suitable for boogie boarding. Lifeguards are on duty here in season.

What are the best months to visit Nantucket?

The months of March, April, September, and October are ideal for a trip to Nantucket. The island is less crowded, and the prices are more reasonable.